Friday, May 4, 2012

The Lord of the Rings (Part One)

Well, my friends, here you have it. We have now mentioned The Hobbit, which is an essential prelude to the Lord of the Rings, and today we can go on to Tolkien's well-known series. I will make the note that I have never seen the movies, and so I will not be able to offer an opinion on them. But if I see them in future, I will let you know. :)

To take my time I'm going to divide up my reviews into three, for the traditional separate volumes. But don't kid yourself; if you decide to read them, they aren't three separate books. The Lord of the Rings is one story, even though for convenience' sake it was broken into three volumes. Read them all at once, for they are only complete all together. (But I really don't have to worry about that, for once you start, you won't stop until you're done. :)

So today, we will talk about The Fellowship of the Ring, the first part of The Lord of the Rings. I had the pleasure, though totally unplanned by me, of reading the editions illustrated by Alan Lee. I would definitely like to own these editions at some point. The pictures greatly resemble the movie casting--does anyone know if he drew them after the movies were made?

And I conscientiously started out with reading Prologue: Concerning Hobbits and Other Matters. ;)

The Story

Three Rings for the Elven-kings under the sky,
Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone,
Nine for the Mortal Men doomed to die,
One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne
In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.
One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them,
One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them
In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.

Part One:

I was thrilled, when I opened to chapter one, to see that I would be hearing more of dear old Bilbo--and Frodo, a delightful new addition. Bilbo is celebrating his eleventy-first birthday, with his adopted heir Frodo Brandybuck, and all the inhabitants of the Shire. At the end of the evening, after the guests have eaten and drunk their fill (and enjoyed some of Gandalf's fireworks), Bilbo puts on his ring and disappears.  He leaves the Shire for good, to spend the rest of his days writing his memoirs with the Elves.

Frodo, his inheritor, lives undisturbed for years until Gandalf returns to the Shire with the tale of the ring. It is the One Ring, the ring of the power of evil, Sauron. And Sauron is out to reclaim it. I won't go into the history of the ring, but leave you to find it out for yourselves. In short, the ring must be carried to the Cracks of Doom in Mordor and destroyed before Sauron can find it. If Frodo does not succeed, then the whole of Middle Earth will be chained under Sauron's evil power.

So he sets out from Bag End to reach Rivendell and take counsel with Elrond. Not alone. His friend, Sam Gamgee, sets out with him, determined not to be left behind, and the hobbits Merry and Pippin come too.
Little by little, Frodo begins to realize the darkness of his quest. Dark horsemen called the Black Riders follow them stealthily,  and they have a legitimate creep factor. And every evil he faces seems to know that he and he alone possesses the Ring. Through disastrous shortcuts, a meeting with old Tom Bombadil, fog, Elves, a belated message from Gandalf, and a meeting with a mysterious guide called 'Strider', they are well on their way in the adventure. After Frodo is pierced by the leader of the Black Riders, time begins to run short. Weary with his wound, which weakens him more and more every day, he must yet overcome it, if he is going to reach Rivendell in time to seek sanctuary and counsel from the Elves.

Part Two:
Though he almost dies, of course Frodo can't quite exit the scene yet. :) At Rivendell the real journey begins. Frodo sets out on his journey into the unknown, and nine companions gather around him:

Thumbnail for version as of 20:25, 25 December 2010
Gandalf the wizard--definitely useful when fighting Balrogs.

File:Sean Astin as Samwise Gamgee.png
 Sam Gamgee--faithful gardener and a jolly good fellow.

Thumbnail for version as of 19:43, 10 December 2005
Pippin--very nice for the humor factor.

Merry--can't be left behind. Goes with Pippin as an indispensable comrade.

Legolas the Elf--excellent with the bow and for running over snow to find ways of escape.

Aragorn son of Arathorn--a kingly leader who does not hesitate to step up and fulfill his calling.

Boromir--eager to persuade the company to come to his city, Minas Tirith. Seems to take an unusual interest in the Ring.

Gimli the Dwarf--eager to use his axe on some enemy. He and Legolas have some very funny lines together.

And not to be left out:
File:Elijah Wood as Frodo Baggins.png
Frodo--a humble little hobbit, rather overwhelmed with his responsibility, but willing to take it on.

And so, Tolkien sets up the cast of characters for the rest of the tale. But as the journey begins, danger turns into tragedy. And by the end of part two, they are no longer travelling all together. I will leave you to find out Who and How and Why.

My Thoughts:

Tolkien's style, his history, and his songs are quite beautiful. While The Hobbit possessed mostly merry ones, and the Lord of the Rings certainly includes the Middle Earth 'folk song' factor, the songs in this trilogy run the gamut from downright morbid to beautifully heartbreaking. Tolkien is one of the writers that leaves you gasping in awe, just with his syntax. He is worth studying more of for anyone who likes to write, or who likes philology. He is truly among the greats in the literary realm.

At first, when I read of Tolkien's account of Frodo's fight with the Ringwraiths, I misunderstood what he meant: [Frodo] bitterly regretted his foolishness, and reproached himself for his weakness of will; for he now perceived that in putting on the Ring he obeyed not his own desire but the commanding wish of his enemies. In reading this, at first I thought that Tolkien was saying that Frodo couldn't help himself. You'll find this a couple of times in the stories. But what Tolkien means in these times is not that the Ring 'forced' itself on Frodo's finger. It finally occurred to me that he is discussing here the fact that we do not always have an inclination to do evil ourselves. Sometimes others desire us to choose evil actions, and their desire is hard for us to withstand. In this case, Frodo didn't hold out long enough to withstand it, and the knife of the Black Rider pierced him.

LOTR is already showing its providential roots in book one: the leaders of the Council, instead of choosing the wisest and the greatest among them to carry the Ring to its fate, (surely the likeliest means to success) choose instead a humble little hobbit, about three feet tall, and not too sure of himself. But the beauty of the Lord of the Rings is that the moral insecurity often found in modern stories is completely non-existent. The characters don't question what's right and what's wrong. They know, and their choice is not to define good, but whether or not they will do it.

In the next two posts we'll discuss more points. I have no special edition today, for those who have read the books, but I anticipate having some thoughts in future. And if I happen to think of any about this book while the Tolkien series is going on, then I will be sure to include them. :)

Lady Bibliophile


  1. Dear Lady B,
    Looks very exciting! Really good post! I liked the pictures. (:

  2. I enjoyed reading your thoughts on the first book, Schuyler! I haven't read any of the books yet, but I did watch part of the first movie with my Mom. It got a little too dark for my taste, but I was not even thirteen yet, so this might be something that I should try watching again-this time, all the way through. :D
    From the excerpt of the book that you gave at the beginning, I was wondering if maybe I should read it instead. Sometimes, it's more interesting to read something with a story line like this, than to watch it. ;) For me, anyway.
    Great job. :)

    1. Thanks; Julianna. :) Yes, the story is a little darker, (especially at 12!) so you might want to start out with the books. The suspense is absolutely non-stop. Actually, you might want to start off with the books anyway, and add in the movies afterwards for fun. There are a couple of very kingly characters in the books that are changed into indecisive leaders for most of the Peter Jackson films. Doesn't spoil the movie for all Tolkien fans, but it's nice to meet them in their best form first. ;)
      Totally up to your Tolkien pleasure... :)


  3. Great review!

    If you think some of the poetry in The Lord of the Rings is morbid, wait till you read "The Mewlips".

    1. Oh, my. Quite. :) I am glad Frodo never had to encounter the creatures; the poor fellow had quite enough as it was.

      Though now that I come to think of it, perhaps 'forboding' would have been a better word to describe some of Tolkien's LOTR poetry. It makes your heart weep for the future, yet delights you at the same time. He must have studied Celtic legend and poetry to achieve that sort of flavor. :)


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...